Why the results of laquinimod are so important?

W
It is time we started doing combination therapy studies. We owe it all the MSers to translate what we have learnt from basic science. #MSBlog #MSResearch


“As you are aware I am very impressed by the laquinimod phase 3 results. Why? Laquinimod is a drug that does not have much effect on inflammatory MS disease activity, i.e. relapses and MRI activity (Gd-enhancing and new T2 lesions). Despite its weak anti-inflammatory effects laquinimod has an impact on disability progression, that appears to be independent of relapses and it slows the rate of brain atrophy. All this points to laquinimod having neuroprotective effects downstream of inflammation. It now appears that laquinimod may be working on glial cell activity and the innate immune system; laquinimod down-regulates the mechanisms responsible for the slow-burn we see in MSers. Are the laquinimod results reliable? Almost certainly they are; why? Mainly because there has been two large phase 3 studies showing the same effect. This makes  the chances of this being a chance result highly unlikely.”


“Are there other drugs that dissociate effects on neurodegeneration and inflammation? Yes, there are. Ibudilast is another drug that prevents brain atrophy but has little impact on inflammatory MS activity. We are so impressed with the effects of ibudilast that we have included it as one of the active treatment arms in our proposed SMART study. The SMART study will be looking at the impact of several agents in SPMS. In addition, a large multicentre study ibudilast funded by the NIH is about to start in the US. I am less confident about the results of ibudilast, when compared to laquinimod, as there are only results from a single phase 2 study to support the drug and there is the potential for ibudilast to make the inflammatory component of MS worse. The ibudilast results could also be a spurious or a false-positive result. Ibudilast is an enzyme inhibitor and is also likely to work downstream of ‘autoimmune inflammation’.”


“It is clear based on my treatment philosophy that both laquinimod and ibudilast need to be tested in combination with an anti-inflammatory therapy. We need to  target both upstream inflammatory events and downstream neurodegenerative events. Only by doing this will be applying what we have learnt from basic science to clinical trial design for progressive MS. In addition, there is a need for combination therapies to be done in early and late MS. Early because there is more brain to save; simply focusing on progressive disease is foolish. By the time MSers enter the progressive phase of  the disease they may have lost too much brain and hence the chances of modifying the course of the disease becomes harder if not impossible. We know from brain atrophy studies that the progressive phase of the disease is there from the outset; the reason why we don’t see it in early disease because the brain is remarkably good at adapting to damage due to its reserve capacity. Once the reserve capacity is exhausted progressive MS ensues relentlessly.”


“Finally, daclizumab (anti-CD25) is another agent that seems to have a greater effect on disability progression relative to its impact on inflammation. This drug is very exciting as it also boosts a component of the so called innate immune system, namely the NK cell. This cell fights infections, in particular viral infections. The latter is why I am so excited about this drug. We now need to wait to see the results of the phase 3 RRMS trial of daclizumab to see if its impact on disability progression is so impressive. If the early results are reproduced there will be a very strong case for taking daclizumab into SPMS and PPMS. The challenge is will two separate studies be necessary or can we convince the regulators that non-relapsing SPMS and PPMS are the same disease. In my opinion, everything points to SPMS and PPMS being the same disease hence my support for combing them in one progressive trial.”


CoI: Multiple

About the author

Prof G

Professor of Neurology, Barts & The London. MS & Preventive Neurology thinker, blogger, runner, vegetable gardener, husband, father, cook and wine & food lover.

10 comments

  • Thats up to TEVA.
    The guantlet has been laid down it is up to them to pick it up and move this forward.
    As you have already told us they have filed patents on laquinimod plus one. lets see the evidence.

    The question is if you have a very good anti-inflammatory do you need an additional neuroprotectant?…however are there any really good, air-tight, anti-inflammatories? and which will be the plus one?, the obvious candidate would be glaterimer acetate asTEVA own both drugs.

    Is it neurprotective will it stop progression, will they take the plunge

    • Did you get involved in the TEVA Laquinimod PPMS study after your answer on January 7? Prof G said yesterday in "DE-FLAMES 2: Putting out the flames" that you are involved in the Laquinimod PPMS clinical study. Fast forward in a few days;D When will we get more details on inclusion/exklusion, study design?

  • "Once the reserve capacity is exhausted progressive MS ensues relentlessly."

    Eurghh…feeling bit flattened by relentless slow worsening in ability to walk but wishing you a Happy New Year and success with your efforts! Pam

    • Due to start in 2014; 12 months recruitment, 2 year study and at least 6 months to close database and analyse the results. I suspect the results will be presented in early 2018.

  • Do you still need a neuroprotection agent if you have NEDA from a highly effective anti-inflammatory? i.e. is it likely sub-clinical (and sub-MRI) downstream damage continues to occur even when there's NEDA based on your definition of this? My sense is there probably is and even if I have NEDA I should still look to take Laquinimod once available?

  • Interesting suggestion to combine PPMS and SPMS in one trial, because they are "the same disease", instead of separating them into two studies. Any thoughts about a possible phase-3 study design? ( size, lenght, end-points )

By Prof G

Translate

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Archives