Falls are problems of Hip fractures in MSers

Bhattacharya RK, Vaishnav N, Dubinsky RM. Is there an increased risk of hip fracture in multiple sclerosis? Analysis of the Nationwide Inpatient Sample.J Multidiscip Healthc. 2014 Feb 13;7:119-22.
BACKGROUND:Impaired ambulation, frequent falls, and prolonged immobilization combined with the high rate of vitamin D deficiency in people with multiple sclerosis (MS) could lead to an increased risk of hip fracture.
METHODS:A retrospective cohort analysis of 20 years of the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (AHRQ.gov), a 20% stratified yearly sample of USA hospital admissions from the year 1988-2007, was performed. Based on International Classification of Diseases Ninth Revision (ICD9) codes, admissions with a primary diagnosis of acute hip fracture and a secondary diagnosis of MS was identified. Indirect adjustment was used to compare the prevalence of MS in this population with that of the USA. Significance was set a priori at P<0.0001 due to the large number of records and multiple comparisons.
RESULTS: A total of 1,066,404 hip fracture admissions were identified and 0.25% had MS. Those with MS were younger, had lower mortality rates (0.25% for people with MS versus 2.97% for those without MS, P<0.0001) and lower rates of discharge to nursing home or rehabilitation (69.25% for people with MS versus 72.17% for those without MS, P<0.0001). When compared with the population prevalence, the predicted prevalence of MS among patients with hip fracture was 2.844 (95% confidence interval [CI] 2.837-2.852) greater than expected when adjusted for age, 2.505 (95% CI 2.499-2.512) when adjusted for sex and age, and 2.175 (95% CI 2.168-2.182) when adjusted for race (white, black). Race was specified for only 65% of the sample.
CONCLUSION: In this nationwide sample of 20 years of hospital admissions in the USA, the prevalence of MS in the population with hip fracture was greater than twice that predicted, and MS patients suffered an acute fracture at an earlier age

Again we have featured good bone health as something that you need to ensure
Prof G says

“The greatest predictor of falls is disability. Preventing disability will prevent MS-related falls and hence fractures. Easier said than done? This is why ProfG promotes early aggressive treatment; by getting on top of inflammation early in the course of MS gives you the greatest chance of preventing disability”

“If you are a faller please speak to your physiotherapist about strategies to prevent falls. In addition, you need to get a bone density scan to see if you have thin bones. Treating thin bones will help reduce your chances of sustaining a fracture. This is also another reason to make sure you are vitamin D replete; vitamin D is good for bones.”

About the author



  • Yes. An MS friend walked round for 15 months with an undxd hip fracture, being told repeatedly by GP and MS nurse that it the pain was to be expected with MS. When at last she ended up in A and E, even their staff were reluctant to X-ray her once they knew she had MS. 17 months on, with her replacement hip, she continues to suffer and at some point will need an operation on her foot, because of the damage caused by the abnormal gait during this period. Can you wonder why many people no longer trust the NHS?

    • Unbelievable……trained professionals could not distinguish between acute pain associated with a fracture and the neuropathic pain of MS. Malpractice attorneys are salivating.

  • Another study from the Journal of the Obvious. So far the list includes: smoking=bad, exercise=good, falling=bad, disability=bad. Sarcasm aside, if people only practiced common sense how much money could be saved in health care?

By MouseDoctor



Recent Posts

Recent Comments